The New First Lady of New York Sparks a Fashion Controversy
When it comes to the world of fashion, the role of the First Lady often commands attention, and the new First Lady of New York, Rama Duwaji, is no exception. Just like Melania Trump had her stylist, Hervé Pierre Braillard, and Michelle Obama worked with Meredith Koop, Duwaji has enlisted the expertise of Gabriella Karefa-Johnson, a former Vogue editor who has made quite a name for herself as a stylist in New York City.
But here’s where it gets controversial: Duwaji’s recent outfit—a vintage Balenciaga coat paired with pointed-toe Shelley boots from Miista—has gone viral. This eye-catching ensemble was curated by Karefa-Johnson, who reportedly sought out the mayor’s wife to showcase her fashion prowess. The incident underscores a long-standing notion that First Ladies may require a guiding hand when it comes to their wardrobe choices.
Karefa-Johnson’s own journey through the fashion world has had its ups and downs. After leaving Vogue under less-than-ideal circumstances, following a heated debate during Paris Fashion Week where she critiqued Gigi Hadid's choice of a Miu Miu t-shirt, she has since found herself in the spotlight once more due to her collaboration with Duwaji. However, this time, the backlash didn’t focus on the stylist but rather on Duwaji herself. Critics quickly pointed out the optics of a “democratic socialist” embracing high-end fashion, especially when her husband, Zohran Mamdani, has been vocal about issues surrounding affordability and social equity.
As the conversation unfolded online, it was revealed that Duwaji's striking look was rented rather than purchased outright—her Balenciaga coat came from Irene Albright’s bi-coastal Albright Library, and the boots were likely loaned from Miista. Yet, this revelation did little to quell the controversy. Even though Miista reported that the Shelley boots are flying off the shelves, some social media users took to harassing those involved in Duwaji's styling.
Interestingly, Karefa-Johnson, after initially giving several interviews discussing her work with Duwaji, has since chosen to remain silent, leading to speculation that she may have signed a non-disclosure agreement with the mayor's office. Attempts by The Hollywood Reporter to reach her for comments have gone unanswered, adding to the intrigue surrounding this story.
So what lies ahead for Duwaji and her fashion choices? Will Karefa-Johnson continue to style New York’s First Lady in the future? And how will Duwaji navigate the scrutiny of her designer fashion choices in the public eye? Her recent fashion shoot published in The Cut, featuring pieces from designers like Jacquemus, Diotima, and Marc Jacobs—all noted as being "on loan"—positions her as a modern-day political style icon reminiscent of 1960s muse Peggy Moffitt.
The fashion industry is certainly keeping a close watch on these developments.
If you’re passionate about insider fashion stories from Hollywood, don’t miss out on subscribing to THR’s “Loose Threads” newsletter by Merle Ginsberg, delivering the latest updates directly to your inbox every week!
